By Catherine Olian, Jessica Hopper, Michelle Balani and Alissa Figueroa
Rock Center
UPDATED: Off the coast of Honduras, divers are dying in search of what they call "red gold." The treasure they're hunting is the lobster that ends up on many American dinner plates.
"Americans should know that every time they eat the lobster, there is a history behind that lobster," said Dr. Elmer Mejia, who has devoted his life to helping the lobster divers.
Mejia has been treating lobster divers for nearly three years at his clinic in La Ceiba, Honduras. The doctor has the only hyperbaric chamber to treat the men who come to him when they are suffering from decompression sickness, commonly called "the bends."
Thousands of men have become permanently disabled working in the unsafe and poorly regulated lobster industry in Honduras. They spend weeks at a time at sea, making as many as 16 dives a day down to depths of 120 feet. Their air tanks often don’t even have pressure gauges to warn them when their supply is running low, so the divers bolt to the surface when they suddenly have trouble breathing. The dangerous combination of staying down too long and coming up too quickly can result in serious decompression sickness and in some cases, paralysis.
"It's incredibly dangerous what they are doing. They are diving so far beyond anything that we would consider to be within acceptable limits," said Eric Douglas, who writes about diving safety and has studied the Miskito divers along with Dr. Mejia. "They have none of the basic things that divers today would consider mandatory equipment- pressure gauges, alternate air sources, even a buoyancy control vest to help them float underwater without effort."
Sometimes the men ignore their difficulty breathing in an attempt to catch one more lobster.
"They get paid by the pound, so the more lobsters they can get on every one of those dives, the more money they make. So they're going to push it for every last breath in the tank," said Douglas.
About 90 percent of their catch ends up in the United States, according to the Honduran government.
Dr Mejia works around the clock at his small clinic treating as many divers as he can. He has very little money, but he doesn’t turn any injured diver away, and what he sees is heartbreaking.
"It's very difficult when you see very young people paralyzed from the neck down below and you know that they will not improve," said Dr. Mejia.
Mejia often travels to the Miskito Coast, a remote area about 200 miles from his clinic where most of his patients live. People there have no electricity or running water. There are few other job opportunities and most families have at least one male relative who became disabled diving for lobsters to be exported to the United States.
In a dilapidated one-room house, Wilmur Mauricio Sambola lay dying. He was paralyzed from the chest down while diving for lobster and he was suffering from a severe infection caused by his illness. Mejia had treated Sambola 10 months earlier and knew that his injuries were severe, but he was still shocked to see how rapidly he had deteriorated.
"He was a very strong man, I'm really surprised at his condition at this moment," said Mejia as he leaned over the ailing man.
During his visit, there was little Mejia could do to treat the 31-year-old man except to provide him with pain medication.
Some 4,500 divers throughout the Miskito Coast have suffered from dive-related injuries like Sambola. Those lucky enough to be healed often return to diving.
"We feel very pleased when they improve very quickly at the chamber, but sometimes we are kind of scared because if they improve so quick, so fast, they will think the hyperbaric chamber makes miracles," said Mejia. "So they will go back again diving and the next time can be the last time."
They take the risk for a few hundred dollars for each two week diving trip. Only the tails of the lobsters they catch are sent to America, and there’s no way the U.S. government, or the consumer, can tell if a lobster tail was caught by a lobster diver.
"Whether they are dive caught or trap caught lobsters, you can't tell, all that we're looking at is the tail," said Agent Paul Raymond of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. There are no laws in the U.S. blocking the import of lobster caught by deep sea divers like the Miskito men.
The Honduran government and regional fishing organizations want to ban lobster diving in 2013, but the divers say they can’t stop because they have no other way to feed their families.
"If we do not provide the job alternatives, stopping the diving will be like killing them," says Dr. Mejia.
There is some hope. USAID just announced that the World Bank is putting together a package of grants and loans for the lobster divers totaling about $775,000. The money is meant to help the Miskito divers develop other ways to make a living, including possibly starting a small artisanal diving industry to catch fish that live in shallow waters, where it’s safe to dive.
Editor's Note: Natalie Morales' full report, 'Lobster Trap,' airs Monday, Jan. 2, at 10 pm/9 c on Rock Center with Brian Williams.















Hey, why not start a "UNION".? Ya right..!
If the divers used gauges showing how much remaining air they had left, they would be responsible for their own safety. This way donations would go a lot further than if an additional hyperbaric chamber or more medical staff was purchased.
The solution to this problem is so obvious, I am surprised the reporting could not see it! Wait, no I'm not, this is MSNBC. Teach saving diving to these people! Jeez, how can you not see that! They are addressing the damage not the prevention for Christ's sake. The divers have no BCD vest's, no weight belts, no back up regulators, dive without a buddy, etc. I'm sorry, but yout reporter was more concerned about her make up and image on camera than a real solution to the problem. Get the Worldwide SCUBA community involved if you want real results to this problem.
[This comment was in response to the aired story and the comments there.]
This story brought tears to my eyes, but reading the comments on this page made me sick to my stomach. The heart wrenching story of these desperate men risking their lives to survive and the generosity of Dr. Mejia is being met with righteous arrogance. I wonder how many of these comments are being left by people who claim to be Christians - your comments are anathema to the love and compassion taught by Jesus.
Until we - the buyers of products in the developed world - are willing to take personal responsibility (that's something right wing conservatives should be willing to accept since they talk so much about it) for the consequences of our actions the world will reflect greed and selfishness ... a world where the values of the profit motive reign supreme. You can see the results of this attitude in our world - dying oceans, melting ice caps, innocent people being killed by weapons made in the USA.
Consumers produce the world, every dollar is a vote. You can live in denial and continue to vote for a world of injustice and environmental degradation, or you can take responsibility by, of example, avoiding products whose production harms people and the environment. If you demand lobster sourced from responsible humanitarian companies, then the market will respond. It might mean paying a little extra for your lobster/eggs/veggies/clothing, but you will be living in truth. (FYI, you can buy humanely harvested lobster from Whole Foods.)
Thank you Brian Williams for sharing this harrowing story.
So Natalie asked how will the divers feed their family, if we boycott dive-caught lobsters? How about feed them lobsters? And they won't have to risk their lives to catch tons and tons of lobsters for our consumption while being paid pennies either.
I also watched last night's story about the Honduran divers. It is truly a shame! What they were catching was originally referred to as crawfish or spiny lobster. For promoting the product, the term lobster was emphasized but this is not where he problem lies.
I have been a Key West dive/fishing captain for over 25 years. I am also a certified dive master and have held certifications with three organizations, YMCA , NAUI & PADI. None of these organizations would support the practices that the commercial divers in your piece endured. Unfortunately, the most important part of the segment was the wonderful work done by the doctor to help the local divers and it seems to have gotten lost.
My wife and I snorkel & dive every year for local lobster in the keys. This product does not only come from outside the country but is a huge domestic product. There might be ramifications from the story to the domestic southern Atlantic and Gulf lobster men that are currently still recovering from hurricane Wilma (which was underplayed by the media) due to Katrina and subsequently the BP oil spill.
The inerrant problem lies with the employers of the divers letting the non certified divers go beyond recreational limits without training or equipment required to safely do the task at hand. To ask the local government to implement and enforce regulations and/or laws would raise the price of the raw product which with basic economics of supply and demand , would balance out and be absorbed by the end consumer. A better situation for the Hondurans, Bahamians , Mexicans and others that import and thus the domestic suppliers would get more for their catch.
Please consider a follow up as the finger seems to be pointed at the product , not the way in which they are harvested.
Respectfully,
Captain. Keith D. Cohen